Brewin' Bruen wrote:Thanks for the mash info. I've been trying to clone this IPA for a while now and thanks to the show I've got some hard data-great work to everyone involved on the BN!
Another quick question for Nathan and Tasty: Green Flash's WC IPA has a brilliant clarity which I'm guessing is the result of filtration, given that the dry hopping would haze the beer. How did the clone's clarity compare to the commercial version? Do you guys recommend filtering dry-hopped brews for competition?
According to the current BJCP guidelines IPAs and Imperial IPAs can display some haziness from dry-hopping. Just curious what you guys think--I'm new to competitions and want to present the best beer possible.
Thanks much.
Greg
Greg,
Yes, you can use a very rough filter to get any remaining yeast/hops out of solution. I think this can strip out a little of the hop flavor/nose, but you can compensate for this by bumping up the dry hop another 25%+ or so. Tasty has talked about this a few times before on the show. Speaking as a BJCP judge I consider some haziness acceptable in American IPAs, especially Imperial IPAs. With appearance as only 3 points/50, that's only 6% of the entire score. If you get a judge who doesn't like to see that haze, if you follow the rest of this recipe your color should be spot on with that 8% C40/carapils and all of the hops in this beer will definitely help you out with head retention, so you'd be at least 2 out of 3 points.
Try it side by side to find out for sure how filtering responds to your process. I brewed 10 gallons of this recipe when brewing it for the radio show. 5 gallons went into a carboy with WLP001, and the other 5 went into a carboy with WLP060 (Cal Ale Blend). 001 finished at 1.015. 060 finished at 1.012. The 001 batch was kindly filtered by Tasty so it would be ready in time for the show, the 060 batch was not. Same dry hop regimen on each. 001 is the one that we tasted on the show. 060 was kegged a few days later after the show was done. Side by side, they're very very close, of course the 060 has some haze compared to the 001. I prefer the 060 slightly because it's a touch drier and the aroma/flavor of the hops is a little stronger. The difference is pretty negligible though.

