rich wrote:Being a certified chef, I consider myself quite versed in food sciences. I have also made sauerkraut for many years, and learned how from my German grandmother (who wrote her recipes out in English) from traditional methods passed down from generation to generation.
With a degree in poli sci you never leave the food service industry I have many years under my belt cooking as well.

rich wrote:Sauerkraut is a fermented food. The acetic acid created by the lactobaccilii has a drastically different flavor than distilled vinegar.
Now I think it's getting to a question of BBQ in the south or potato salad in Germany every town/region has a local style. While it may have started fermented, pickling versions are just as popular depending on region. There is more than white distilled vinegar, I would never use that for food, more often for cleaning.
rich wrote:Un-pounded kraut, often will not ferment all he way through, and usually has a rubbery texture.
Bad cook who has that, I have never had that issue with pickling.
rich wrote:Try it out for yourself. I think you'll find the result is not the same. Why wait 3-8 weeks for beer when you can drink it in 4 days?
Just because it's different doesn't make it better nor worse, I am inclined to think it's a style difference. At that point you are at why malt extract when you could all grain, for me I don't have space for all grain, likewise I doubt I'd have room for the fermenting cabbage...besides I suspect my dog would get into while I was away.
I suspect we are quickly getting into a style debate along the lines is NC pork bbq or Texas brisquet. There are many paths to sauerkraut and they are often tasty.