I kind of like how the recirc on a brew-magic system works. No sparge ring... it just uses a hose. Nice and simple. I posted a short video of it on my blog and how I modified my MLT to do the same thing...
Video and pictures...
Keg to Mash Tun Conversion with RecircKeep in mind, I just finished putting it together and haven't used it so I can't say how well it works yet. I'm expecting it to perform like the one in the video. We'll see...