BDawg wrote:I got sick of looking for others to give me feedback, so I studied and took the BJCP exam myself.
Now I don't ever need to rely on anyone else to give me feedback. I evaluate it for myself.
BDawg-
BJCP GM1
PS - If anyone ever wants me to give them feedback (with or without a score sheet) on a beer for them, I'm always open. Just pm me.
First of all ... take advantage of any club that you have in the area. Hopefully they have some BJCP judges. Our local club is relatively new and now has three.
Also, I can tell if my BMC friends really like a beer if they continue to drink from my taps instead of going to their brought cooler with BMC ... more of a pass/fail type of an analysis and only works for certain styles.
Entering in competitions has really helped me to get an idea on the quality of beer I am producing. I usually enter it into a local comp and the NHC at the same time to get differing feedback and save at least one beer to drink while I am reading the feedback. After a couple of years doing that, I have a relatively good idea how well a beer will score and am able to calibrate my palate to others. With costs in consideration, send a few and extrapolate to your other beers.
As bdawg suggested, the best option is to become your own critic ... or find a virtual "brewpal" that you can send beers to for evaluation and in return you receive beers to evaluate yourself. I have been looking for such a scenario with a few promising folks, but have yet to solidify any arrangement. .... any takers?