Beer Forum

This is a forum for enlisted and new recruits of the BN Army. Home brewers bringing it strong! Learn how to brew beer, trade secrets, or talk trash about your friends.
https://www.thebrewingnetwork.com/forum/

Top Cropping from my carboy???

https://www.thebrewingnetwork.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=24340

Page 1 of 2

Top Cropping from my carboy???

Posted: Thu Mar 10, 2011 5:15 pm
by ShakesBeer
Here's the deal. I can't really top crop easily with the small opening at the top of my carboy and I really don't trust myself enough to wash the yeast from the trub without contamination. Can I just top off my 6.5 gallon carboy with 6-6.5 gallons and run a blow off to a sanitized container(with an airlock) to maximize the collection. I'm concerned that there's something I'm not taking into consideration and whether or not the top cropped yeast would be ideal for reuse. The OG is 1.073, about 50 IBU's and the yeast is WLP001 California Ale with a servomyces nutrient.

Re: Top Cropping from my carboy???

Posted: Thu Mar 10, 2011 8:52 pm
by spiderwrangler
Top cropping will generally get you some nice yeast. Filling your carboy all the way to the top just to get yeast seems like a long way to go though, and fools around with your first batch's recipe. If you run a tube down your stopper, you can keep it just above the liquid layer and yeast will be forced up the tube into your collection vessel. If you are using a carboy hood, you can apply VERY low pressure from the other tubing to collect more quickly. If you collect quickly, you have less to worry about getting a plugged stopper, etc. The hood is more likely to blow off before cracking the carboy, but be careful anytime applying any pressure to a glass vessel.

Re: Top Cropping from my carboy???

Posted: Thu Mar 10, 2011 10:56 pm
by ShakesBeer
I don't really mind adjusting my recipe to top off the carboy as long as I'm not adding anything later on in the fermentation. But I'm fitting the clear hose through the rubber stopper and into the blow off container like you suggested. I like hearing that the top cropped yeast would work well but other than the adjustments in the recipe, would anything like head preassure from the extra volume and lack of head space, impede the fermentation in anyway?

Re: Top Cropping from my carboy???

Posted: Fri Mar 11, 2011 6:21 am
by spiderwrangler
Shouldn't really be any additional head pressure, may even be less depending on how you have your blow off set up. If it's just going into a container that's able to vent (foil it over), it won't have to push a column of water to be able to release the CO2. Just make sure it doesn't plug up. Increasing your volume means that everything that rises is going to be concentrated and pushed out, which potentially could plug something.

Re: Top Cropping from my carboy???

Posted: Fri Mar 11, 2011 10:22 am
by TastyMcD
ShakesBeer wrote:....I can't really top crop easily with the small opening at the top of my carboy ......


Sure you can. Take a piece of racking that's long enough to go through your carboy stopper and into the krausen just above the liquid line. Attach tubing to the piece of racking cane and into your yeast collection jar. (Everything sanitized, of course.)

Tasty

Re: Top Cropping from my carboy???

Posted: Fri Mar 11, 2011 1:14 pm
by ShakesBeer
Thanks for the tips guys! I have 6 gallons in there now with a racking tube going to a sanitized container and with high krausen it's filling up fast. It looks like a lot of wort is running off too. Should I store it as is, or cool it down and decant once it settles down? It's going to be about 7% abv wort and I wasn't sure if that was too strong for a couple weeks of storage in the fridge?

Re: Top Cropping from my carboy???

Posted: Fri Mar 11, 2011 3:10 pm
by spiderwrangler
TastyMcD wrote:
ShakesBeer wrote:....I can't really top crop easily with the small opening at the top of my carboy ......


Sure you can. Take a piece of racking that's long enough to go through your carboy stopper and into the krausen just above the liquid line. Attach tubing to the piece of racking cane and into your yeast collection jar. (Everything sanitized, of course.)

Tasty



This was what I was attempting to describe... :bnarmy:

Re: Top Cropping from my carboy???

Posted: Fri Mar 11, 2011 4:37 pm
by BrewWein
Hey just adding another method that I've been using. Little more complicated, but in the month I've been doing it its helped a lot in learning about yeast growth, aroma smells, taste ect...

I am attempting to start having ready yeast on hand when ever I want (I brew at least once a week) but live in a very small apartment and can't devote an entire room as the designated yeast room. Also I don't really want to screw around rinsing the yeast out of my 6.5 gallon glass carboys (the hop residue and junk that sticks to the top of the head space makes me too nervous). I've concluded if I top-crop into starters and continually growing the yeast up I'll have ready yeast whenever. Now unfortunately I don't have one of those niffty orange carboy caps where I could stick a racking cane, and I have no spoon small enough to reach down into the carboy. I do have however a couple of of the little metal eye rods, like the ones used for agar plates. I have a temp controlled chest freezer in the back room (yeah the bed room) and I'm hoping that by spraying all around with some star san even before I take the airlock out the air with be clean enough. So after I sprayed, I took what I'm going to guess as about a 50 mL test tube with maybe 15-20 mL of boiled water and began "scooping" at the foamy top of the beer, which is about 30 hours or so in and bubbling nicely. I meant to keep dipping the eye rod into a measuring cup of star san which had the test tube cap in it, but must have breathed in some CO2 and forgot... I probably "scooped" ten or so times, trying to make sure I got some pure foam, some hop residue, I also tried to the best I could going down through the foam to the very top of the surface but I felt like I was just ending up washing it. I'm not really sure where the best place to collect only a couple of yeast cells is? The sterile water was around 65, like the beer, but maybe a little hotter is the temp difference going to affect the yeast more because there are only a few cells? I do mainly ales but only cuz im impatient and have no heat pad. Once I finished I quickly screwed the cap on(tight) and popped the airlock back in. Next (on top of chest freezer, cuz it means I don't even have to leave the room) I took a flask of starter wort I had just made- 1.040 with gypsum yeast nutrient and yeast energizer added- and I poured around 15-20 mL of that into the test tube (after taking a butane lighter the the mouth of the test tube) I screwed back on the cap (tight) and dipped in quickly into the star san. Hoping to sanitize the parts the wort poured on? Is my guesstimate wrong that half boiled water and half 1.040 wort and I'll have a 1.020? I"m doing all the liquid measurements by guessing because it seems more sanitary that way, but would being more precise be better? So with about 40 mL in the test tube there is a 10 mL head space. I was flipping the test tube all around (tightly capped) because I figured that would give it more surface area to aerate. Now I have the test tube up right on a closet shelf with the cap loose. Now my plan is after 2 days pour the test tube into a 500 mL flask but I'm not sure if the wort should be 1.020 again or if I should bump it up to the 1.040 yet? Two days after that 1000mL flask at 1.040, then I don't really have a bigger flask so I would end up brewing again and pitching this flask. Sorry its a little wordy but I wanted to get as much of my process in as I could think of. Any critique of my process would be greatly appreciated. Is this even going to work? I felt a little skeptical about gathering enough yeast. Do I need to start out with even smaller volumes? I know just getting and orange cap and a drip tube would probably be easier but I also feel like keeping this up will help me work with yeast. Also if you noticed, my yeast is never really going into the fridge, the biggest drop is from room temp starter to 5 gallons of 62 degree beer. Would it be better though if I placed it in the fridge during the 500mL stage so I could decant it? Will my math be off for the gravity in the 1000mL if I don't decant? Finally my last question is should my test tube gravity only be 1.020, for example this particular beer is a 1.060 amber ale with white labs 001 cal ale yeast, the yeast is in tip top shape, but because I'm collecting so few should it go into the 1.020 wort?


I just copied that from my post on homebrewtalk ( http://www.homebrewtalk.com/f163/can-i- ... ay-222607/ ) so pay too much mind to all my questions. Also FYI, it took me a few practice "batches" before I was comfortable enough to actually throw this yeast in a full batch.


Finally, if tasty or spiderwrangler, or anyone else for that matter sees this, I'm curious about the difference between top cropping generations and normal yeast washing generations. What I mean is I hear Jamil talk a lot about the higher quality of beer with 3rd and 4th and so on generation yeast, but I'm concerned that by cropping the yeast before its been through a full fermentation cycle I'm loosing something (Im not sure what I'd be loosing, but maybe something flavor contributions/characteristics) So I guess the question is, does the anaerobic (without oxygen right?) stage of fermentation have an affect on future generation's characteristics, or will I see the same results with yeast cultured from the growth period?

All times are UTC - 8 hours
Page 1 of 2