I've fermented many times with 001, and it's very happy at 68 (internal temp). Now I'm fermenting with 1056 at 65 degrees, and it's blown through the airlock on 4 consecutive days. That never happens to me with any yeast because I ferment in large, wide buckets, with low fermenation temperatures, and leave about 5 inches of head space. This one is fermenting at 58 degrees ambient. Now, I have this sulfur smell coming from the 1056 bucket. I know the sulfur will eventually dissipate, but I've never had that with 001. Also, I want to dry hop this beer near the end of fermentation, and I'm not sure how I feel about tossing a lot of hops into a sulfurous beer. One of my dry hops will be Columbus which, like Apollo and Summit, has a tendency to leave a bit of a sulfur character. In addition to being cleaner, the 001 yeast also appears to be more flocculant. The only similarity that I'm finding is that they're both very attenuative. When I ferment with a clean and neutral yeast, I want it to be clean and neutral. I won't be using 1056 again. Other than the Rogue strain and the West Yorkshire strain, I've not been impressed with Wyeast's products. They're far inferior to White Labs. Here is a blog I found about a side by side experiment with 001 and 1056; the experimenters also have sulfur coming from the 1056:
WLP001 v Wyeast 1056 Results
The citra IPA Jeremy and I recently brewed was the first batch I've actually oxygenated vs simply aerated. After reading Yeast by Jamil Zainasheff and Chris White, I decided to invest the few bucks in a mostly proper oxygenation setup in order to get my fermentation that much more optimal. We brewed for a ten gallon yield, split the batch in half and pitched starters of WLP001 and Wyeast 1056 into two separate fermentors. Each 5 gallon better bottle got a 30 second shot of pure oxygen through a 5 micron stone. Both 2 liter starters were treated identically with yeast nutrient and splitting time on the stir plate.
Fermentation took off pretty quickly for both (an expected outcome) but over the course of fermentation, I experienced a level of attention from WLP001 which was a completely unexpected outcome.
OG on this beer was 1.065 and the target finishing gravity should have been around 1.016. On this batch the WLP001 made it all of the way down to 1.008. This puts the attenuation rate at 85% instead of the typical 75%. The Wyeast ended up right around 1.016. Jeremy got the WLP batch, so I haven't had the opportunity to do a side by side of carbonated, conditioned beer, but my preliminary tasting indicated that the WLP version was more neutral and thinner than the Wyeast version. The latter had some of the faint sulfury character I've picked up on the last few batches we've fermented with Wyeast 1056.