Mine turned out a little darker than the real thing, but I'm really pleased with it. I had an OG of 1.091 and ended up with 10% abv. Mine turned out to have a little less aroma than the real thing, and doesn't have quite as much caramel sweetness (maybe due to the higher alcohol content), but it is very good. I'll definitely brew the recipe again.
In addition to overshooting the OG, I also left it on the dry hops for way longer than the recipe calls for. Maybe that has something to do with the lesser aroma...it sat for a couple extra weeks before it was kegged, and I may have lost a lot of the volatile aroma compounds.
Gordon on the left, homebrew on the right. Poor head due to sloppy pour. They're both also clearer than the pic makes them look.